Gears of War 3 vs Uncharted 3 the better game?

[Jexy]

dsage01 said:

No use arguing with a man who never even played UC3 MP. Your comparing it with COD really? That's why it got a 2.0 (PS3 and 360 versions) from Metacritic users right? And come on there's no reason to bring sales in this. Most people who play Cod are girls or 12 year olds and you want to compare that wwith Uncharted? Shame on you

They're called trolls for a reason.  When 2000 people create accounts in metacritic just to give MW3 a 0 for a rating, you actually take that as gospel?  Please.  Think about it... if it has an overall 8.9 rating out of 10 by all REAL reviewers, and its by far the most played game, do you really think most people think it's a 3.1 (currently what it's at on metacritic for the 360)?  It's just a bunch of angry fan boys of both consoles who are upset that it's going to outsell their favorite game 5 times over.  It's the most successful and because of that, the most hated on game in history.  COD is the biggest baddest kid on the block, whether you like it or not.  Most of the people I know playing it are men in their 20's and 30's who get together after a hard days work. Maybe that's because of who I know and talk to, or maybe because ALL age groups play MW3 more than any other game.  Who knows...

I'm not comparing the game as a whole to UC3, I'm telling you that it's a multiplayer based game, like Halo and Gears.  UC3 is a better game than MW3 overall, but for multiplayer only, which one are people running to play and posting a million vids on youtube about... I see those numbers for Halo, Gears, COD, etc... for a reason.  Uncharted on Metacritic has a 9.2... 0.3 higher than MW3... which means Metacritic doesn't have a problem with comparing the two.  People need to stop being a hater of the most popular game on the market, which no doubt, directly leads to more sales of your favorite game and helps the industry as a whole.