By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Aldro said:
TruckOSaurus said:

 

People seem to like UC3, and the few who say that UC2 is better seem to feel that UC2 had a more fresh feel to it when it came. Obviously thats understandable. My question to those is:
Would you still rather play UC2 than UC3 though? Obviously UC3 is new, and to me it is far better in every aspect (I know some disagree), but 

Most reviewers disagree dude. The fact is Uncharted 2 is the better game because it has more sustained shooting sequences throughout the game. It has a better ending because  (SPOILER) there is actually a semi challenging boss fight. Uncharted 3 has too many pace slowing puzzles in the first half. The intro to the fighting is so slow to a veteran of the series and as a person who likes a challenge it is very boring. 

Uncharted 3 has less replay value because its use of story and gameplay are fun the first time through, but for a 2nd trip (pun intended) through the game relying on story less than shooting makes for a less enjoyable experience because you already know what happens. When gunplay is put ahead of story going back and playing the game at a more difficult level remains fun because it remains challenging. Quit simply the story formula is totally like uncharted 2 only the script is changed. I will say UC3's script is better, but when it uses the same kinds of twists to make the story it losses originality.

In all, the campaign is worse, but the multiplayer is better.