Twas the Night Before Christmas-Mafia Round 35

[Stefl1504]

theprof00 said:

Stefl1504 said:

theprof00 said:

I'm surprised nobody has commented on this yet.

When you say "I would believe it if there was more than one daytime role". What are you getting at? I don't know if there are daytime roles, but I'm also not sure about it. This seems like a weird reason to vote.

 

But I digress. I'm intrigued to see that you've voted, finally. Though I feel like you wanted to vote, but had no reason?

vote; ST

Yeah you are pointing it out, we don't know if there is any daytime role at all (since MDJ was vanilla), also my vote is cast against him because I don't like his roleclaim not because I don't know if there are any other daytime roles - and if he is a daytime roleblocker - thats no reason for him to not be Mafia since roleblockers are often mafia... also that roleclaim seemed to be panicky he was like "omg I have 2 votes on me I have to think of something" - at least it felt to me like that...

except that nobody has commented about day roles. You made that decision.

And all your reasoning is really bad. There are plenty of good reasons to lynch him, but you have some of the weirdest ones. It feels to me like you're avoiding the potential accusation of parroting (except for that part where yu credit MG)

And make no mistake, if you kill me, you aren't going to solve your problems. You hesitated on ST without any good reason and you have strange reasoning for the vote once it IS placed.

Also, your vote was:

"Actually... I don't like that roleclaim one bit... its far too non vanilla for my taste - and I would only believe it if there was more than one daytime role"

Not only did you make the decision that a role can't exist because it's too non-vanilla, despite the fact that nobody should know the setup, but that your reasoning also assumes the types of roles. So above, your statement was about your reasoning having nothing to do with the other roles is entirely false. It's in the very sentence where you say "I don't like that roleclaim one bit". It's not a "furthermore", it's not an "additionally", it's part of your main reasoning.

Yeah, but it isn't that I am afraid of parroting its just that I don't like to parrot - so I just don't talk about that stuff that seems to be clear already - and for me the tipping point was when he roleclaimed, though it was not nearly necesary - because of the roles I already know (MDJs and mine) I have to think of this game as vanilla - and I would believe it if he claimed (normal-nighttime) cop or something like that, but a daytime roleblocker was just too much for me to believe a word he spoke - even if he is town he outright lied (at least in my eyes), and just because of the lying I have voted for him, and normally Mafia tend to lie and Town should not lie, specially when he isn't in a situation where he wasn't under such pressure that he had to think of something, instead he was trying to defend his actions with a stupid, stupid lie - and I would be happy if someone can tell me that he 100% didn't lie, for me theres no benefit of the doubt here... and when he wasn't Mafia and a daytime roleblocker, well then I fucked up - otherwise he fucked up by telling a lie .