VGC Atheists,Whats your reason?

[setsunatenshi]

snakenobi said:

setsunatenshi said:
Snakenobi, your arguments are filled what are called logical fallacies...

Just to point out a few, straw man arguments:

when you are putting all atheists into 1 bandwagon pretending all agree with what you're arguing against. In this case you're forgetting that apart from 'i don't believe in the existence of a god' there's nothing else you can unite all atheists in.
As an example, the Buddhists you so much seem to praise ARE atheists too.

Buddhist are pantheist.Buddhist's live a moral life

 

real atheist wouldn't behave morally as they don't believe in consequences

pantheist are atheist who are moral.

 

i am trying to tell pantheists who wrongly identify themselves as an atheist

This is pretty amazing, from my entire post you decide to address only this part refering to where you use a strawman argument... and you use the same strawman argument again.

I'll try it in another way...

 

What gives you the right to decide what a 'real' atheist views on morality are? Who are you to say how a 'real' atheist will act? Why would you say a 'real' atheist doesn't believe in consequences?

Example used: Person X goes around all the people he/she knows and decides to be absolutely honest in pointing out the flaws he/she sees in them. Mary, you're way too fat. Paul, you're one of the most stupid people I know. John, you have an awful odor, I can't stand being near you. Anna, you are dumb as a rock but I would love to have sex with you. Andy, you talk too much and everyone I know hates you. Etc...

 

Did person X act morally because he/she spoke what he/she perceived was the truth?

Will this attitude towards other people displayed by person X carry any consequences in his/her life?

Can you tell wether person X is an atheist or a person with any kind of theistic belief?

 

Thank you for playing... baby steps, baby steps...