just when you thought the uncharted 3 reviews could not get any worse...

[smbu2000]

trasharmdsister12 said:

Machina said:
He didn't review Gears actually, that was someone else on their site (gz on trying to turn it into a PS3 v 360 war thing though :S).

Yeah, if you look at all the reviews he has written, his scores seem to be all over the place. Halo Reach got a B-, Fight Night Championship got a B+, Shift 2 Unleashed got a B, Kinect got a C+, Rage got a C+, Mafia 2 got a C-, etc.

I just think this guy wrote the review based on his preferences and he clearly doesn't seem to like the design of the cinematic game or the use of smooth animation meshing at the cost of instant control. Whether he's entitled to write the review in his opinion, or put it in the mindset of one who appreciates that style of game is a whole different discussion.

I'm not so sure about that. The same guy reviewed Uncharted 2 for that site 2 years ago and he gave that game an A. Maybe he was actually disappointed with UC3?

http://www.avclub.com/articles/uncharted-2-among-thieves,33912/