"Why I'm Agnostic" (Good read for believers and non-believers)

[Cirio]

Jay520 said:

MS10 said:and the reason we have freewill but he ask us to follow his rules here is so he can weed out the bad!because heaven wouldn't be heaven with bad people who do bad things with there freewill.so your born to be tested to see if with your freewill you can handle living forever with other people in heaven so it's great for everyone because we keep our freewill forever.just something for people who don't believe in god or religion to think about!

Why would a just God decide to blame the people when they are 'bad' when it is him who gave people their flaws, and it is him who decided to give insufficient evidence of his existence to these flawed people? Why is it that even if one person doesn't find his 'way' (and statisticly speaking, out of billions of imperfect people, some of them are gaurranteed to be 'bad') then that person is blamed and ousted to an eternity of torture?

In my religion, it is believed that God creates all humans as "good" and "pure". In life, the human has the choice of remaining "pure" and "good" by following the suggestions of God, or he can go "bad" by following the temptations of Lucifer/satan. God gave humans a brain to be able to resist the temptations of satan and to ultimately embarrass him by not following his orders. Those humans who constantly do bad are those who have been convinced by satan to do bad. Those who are "good" are those who ignore him. So according to my beliefs, what MS10 said was wrong, because God wants every one of his creations to go to heaven, and there is no "weeding out" of the bad. It's Lucifer's goal to make sure God's creations fail, thus we have "bad" people.

That's all I'm gonna say. I hate religious discussions on online forums.