By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
osamanobama on 27 October 2011
Edit Thread
Michael-5 said:
osamanobama said:
 

its ignorant because its not grounded in reality or popular opinion.

sure you can personally think Uncharted multiplayer is boring (though i dont know how, no other game, has nearly as much varrying gameplay), thats fine. but to generalize definitifely stating it is boring, and doesnt deserve a 10 because of that. is ludicrous, as well as say "since not everyone thinks its perfect then it doesnt deserve a 10" then you go on to say Zelda deserves/close to a 10.  is hilarious. and then you go on to say no game deserves a 10 (didnt see you complaining about the 10's Gears, forza and Halo got), why iven have that score then, reviewers should rate based off a 0-9.5 system then, whats the point of the 10.

also ign almost unanimously reviewers rave about Uncharted's multi is amazing, saying it could be sold as its own full price game. you are alone in thinking its average and boring (though its laughable that you base that off 20 min of player, if you actually did play that much). literally you are alone in this one, how you think it is boring is beyond me (well actually its not, that is a very common trend on which games you find boring)..

and a game can be designed for both Single player, and multiplayer, which Uncharted clearly is. the devs spent tons of time perfecting both. also most reviewers have been saying the campaign is about the same length as Uncharted 2, and or a Dozen or so hours.

and again your last paragraph cant possible be serious can it? ND does multi because they want to, and they are great at it. it couldnt be anything further from being tacked on, it was planned on in the beginning, and was perfected, and the reviewers shared those sentiments, praising both U2 and U3 for some of the best multi out there.  you say so definitevely that it boring, tacked-on,, unnatural, yet you are virtually the only person that thinks so.

How you think Uncharted 2/3 beta multiplayer is anything but average baffles me....Maybe your just used to average MP games.

I know there is no point arguing with you.

IGN is giving out 10's too easily, this is a great game, but IGN is a terrible review website nowdays. 9.8/10, I'd accept, UC3 is likely a great game (judging from UC2). 4 10's in 3 years is too much..

Uncharted was built to be a single player game, the mechanics just don't commute to MP. That was the case in UC2, and judging by the beta it's the same in UC3. The review said the MP isn't perfect, and they give rewards too frequently.

IGN said the campaign was short (yes they did say short) at about 8 hours, not a dozen. Stop plain out lying.

Not going to argue anymore. Your far too insulting, and you twist my arguements to make me look like a 360 fanboy...(didn't see me complain about the scores Halo, Gears, and Forza got, why just list 360 games? Did any of these get 10/10?).

If I don't agree with you 100% I'm a fanboy, you want to make me out to be one, and I refuse to debate with someone like this. It's rude, and plain uncivil.

Seriously osama, it's a great game. Get a life. People will not agree with you 100%. If IGN gave Halo a 10/10 I'd say the exact same thing, but there would also be 10 other people saying it, and no one would attack me. Why does it have to be this hard to say anything negative about any PS3 exclusive?

ClassicGamingWizz - I never said the game doesn't deserve a high score. I said it's a great game, but IGN shouldn't be giving out 10's so easily. No game should get a 10 unless it defined the entire generation and introduced a whole new method of gameplay. UC3, no matter how much better then UC2 it may be, is still largely similar to UC2, and that was a 9.5/10 on IGN? I'm saying the game deserves a 9.8/10, but ANYTIME, ANY FREAKEN TIME, I say the slightest negative comment on any PS3 exclusive, I will get attacked by 5 people.

lol, man your too funny.

like i said YOU and ONLY YOU think Uncharted multiplaer is average, its not just me thinking its amazing, its EVERYONE. almost unanimously reviewers have praised Uncharted 2 multiplayer, some going as far as to say "it could be sold as its own full priced game", and now reviewers are saying Uncharted 3's multiplayer is much much better. in fact some site gave it the best multiplayer of E3.

and when did i ever say ign said its campaign was a dozen hours  (actually i cant remember ign even referencing the lenght)

then you talk about how 10 is too high, 9.8 you can accept (a score they dont give), how can you say that about a game that you have never played.

and for the other games, go to metacritic.com, is it really that hard to check the reviews on that site, those games got plenty of 10's none of which you complained about.

and i dont give a hell if you dont like the game, but when you go around stating YOUR OPINIONS as facts, or as common shared believes, thats where i have the problem.

YOU ARE LITTERERALLY THE ONLY PERSON WHO THINKS UNCHARTED'S MULTIPLAYER IS AVERGE.

and guess what when people really love the single player, and really love its multiplayer, and really love everything about it, finding little to no faults, they sometimes give out a 10.

your opinion of this game isnt shared by nearly anybody