By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Aldro on 25 October 2011
Edit Thread
non-gravity said:
Aldro said:

Yeah im talking about the HD Twins. Nintendo just rocks too much to be in the comparison ;). Out of Microsoft and Sony, the greatest exclusive franchise of this generation based on acclaim has to be Uncharted ^_^.

Uncharted: 88 + 96 + 93 = 277

Gears of War: 94 + 93 + 91 = 278

Unless you want to pull the 'Gears 1 is on pc' card.

Also:

Mass Effect: 91 + 96 + ? = 

Mass effect 2 is multiplatform, I consider Mass effect 1 as a multiplatform too.

Gears of War ...same applies here.

Uncharted 1 didnt even get AAA status, so why bother counting it.

I am talking about Uncharted 2 and Uncharted 3 having an insane critical acclaim out of the exclusives.
Gears 2 and 3 did not have the same acclaim that Uncharted 2 and 3 have/are having.
ME 2 has a chance depending on ME3 next year BUT ..I am speaking exclusives mate.

 

But if we were to count them according to your merits =
Mass Effect 1 + 2 = 91 + 96 = 187
Gears 1 +2 +3 = 94 + 93 + 91 = 278
Uncharted 1 + 2 + 3 = 88 + 96 + 94 = 278

^Uncharted 3 currently has a 94 metacritic.

My merits =

ME 2 + 3 = 96 + ?
Gears 2 + 3 = 94 + 93 = 187
LBP2+1 = 95 + 92 = 187 <- had to add XD
Uncharted 2 + 3 = 96 + 94 = 190

But I am not merely going by metacritic either. Uncharted 2 recieved so much acclaim and GOTY awards in 2009 that I find it quite shocking that Naughty Dog was able to improve on that and land on a 94 metacritic which is very likely to recieve a few GOTY's once again. (Although time will tell). No disrespect meant to Epic Games or Bioware.

I am simply saying Naughty Dog is the top PS3 exclusive developer and it really stood out this generation.

EDIT:
LBP2+1 = 95 + 92 = 187