IGN - Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception Review!!!

[lestatdark]

mantlepiecek said:

pezus said:

Michael-5 said:

yo_john117 said:

Cirio said:

non-gravity said:
but but is it better than Mass Effect 2?

Nothing but Mass Effect 3 can be better than Mass Effect 2. But Uncharted 2+3 are 3rd best :P

I have to say I can't disagree with you on that :D

http://xbox360.ign.com/articles/106/1064323p1.html

IGN, the people who gave Uncharted 3 a 10/10, also said that Mass Effect 2 is a better game then Uncharted 2, and made that article to back themselves up.

Mass Effect 3... will be huge. If IGN gave UC3 a 10/10 for a perfect story and tacked on multiplayer, I expect ME3 to get the same from them.

I'm sorry but if recent Bioware games are any indication there's no way in hell that ME3 gets a 10. And a perfect story?? WTH, ME2's story was just bad (while the storytelling was pretty good), gameplay was uninspired, repetitive mini-games etc. etc. 

And UC3's multiplayer is certainly not average. It's very good, not perfect but still very good. The beta did not play like the full game, so you are judging it unfairly.

Edit: And wow, I had totally forgot about this article. What a flamebait! He's trying to push his opinion on his readers: "I'm telling you that Mass Effect 2 is better than Uncharted 2. I need you to accept this. "This and the "Where in the world is Gran Turismo?" article really points out how this site works.

Not a single fan of ME 2 will accept its flaws. No one ever does it. When people say it has limited rpg elements...the answer is " you played it on easy ", when people say it has repetitive missions, the answer is "everything is repetitive".

Woah, hold your horses on the generalization. Mass Effect is my second favourite series this gen, but I too see that ME2 had a lot of flaws, especially when compared to the first game. Yeah the limited RPG elements are a nuisance, even when played on Insanity (which boils down to using the same skill over and over again), yeah it has repetitive missions (again when compared to ME), it has one of the worst minigames ever (the scanning mission) and they took everything I loved from the inventory management from the first one. 

But ME has and will always be about the story, which is one of the most engaging sci-fi stories ever written, be it for a videogame or any other medium, and while ME focus more on the overall story, ME2 focused more on the characters. I hope that ME3 brings the conclusion for both sides and manages to bring back some of the elements from the first one (the weapon customization seems to be overhauled from the first one, and the addition of skill trees adds much more variants to the RPG elements). 

So please, stop your pointless and ridiculous generalizations, when it's only a few members here on VGC or a few ME fans that claim that about ME2.