So I really think that Uncharted 3 is getting the shaft on metacritic

[non-gravity]

In 2009 Batman Arkham Asylum received the most GOTY awards after Uncharted 2. Strangely enough B:AA only received a 91/92 metacritic, which is a few points down from normal GOTY's. I suspect this is because it was made by an unproven developer and critics didn't expect the coming of Jesus.