It's an almighty pain to update this thread when scores fluctuate so much. SO, no I'm not abandoning the thread! But I do suppose some new rules.
The score counted will be the version with the most review scores, this is the version less likely to fluctuate. When you have a 360 version with 65 reviews, and a PS3 version with 29, but the PS3 version has the higher score, not only is the PS3 score not the definitive meta score, but it's much more likely to fluctuate.
However, if a higher scored sku is within 10 reviews of the highest reviewed version (or whatever I deem realistic ie 80 to 100 would be OK because they're so high) then the highest score will be counted.
If anyone has a problem with this please let me know, I feel this is the best way forward though, some games are going to fluctuate like made over the next couple of months because they have so little reviews yet are the highest score.
I'll also be doing a full update today/tomorrow
4/11/11
Essay Pro