Uncharted 3; GOTY hands down!

[sweatface7]

coolbeans said:

sweatface7 said:

pezus said:

sweatface7 said:

Adobo said:
I agree but Gears 3, Skyrim and Dark Souls may have a shot...

gears 3 maybe, but skyrim idk, seems to long of a game and i dont even know what the story is about? lol

The Elder Scrolls has never been about the story, it's the freedom and openness that is awesome

true, ive never played any of the games tho so i didnt know.. but how could a freeroam game win goty? thats like saying GTA4 is goty worthy when it wasnt that great to me..

Why does the game have to only be great in your eyes to win GOTY?  We all have different tastes on what "greatness" actually is.  After diving into Fallout 3 (although I haven't completed it yet), I'd give Fallout 3 a 7.5.  I'm fine with it being recognized at one of 2008's best games since it's an opinion.

uhhh because its my opinion thats why?