By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
trasharmdsister12 said:
Simple question for those who have played Demon Souls and Ninja Gaiden 1/Black for Xbox. Which game has more difficult combat/encounters when you first attempt the game? I'm wondering which of these has harder fights? I'm not talking about how the design of the game influences its overall challenge (ie. Not being able to save for long periods of time), but just the encounters and battles themselves the first time you go at them.

I would personally say Ninja Gaiden. While I do think some people in this thread are underrating Demon's Souls difficulty, it is still a challenging game, but a lot of the difficulty comes down to strategy more than skill. Ninja Gaiden requires combat mastery and quick reactions. Demon's Souls requires the same but to a lesser extent. To me, it is much more forgiving if you are talking about a first playthrough, especially with the plethora of healing items and the ability to summon other people. Now, if you are talking about higher difficulties, Ninja Gaiden easily takes the crown.