The Ico & Shadow of the Colossus REVIEW thread - 92 on Metacritic!!

[sensebringer]

Fufinu said:

sensebringer said:
can someone explain to me why ign gave this collection of two great games an 8.5, when they gave the original shadow of colossus a 9.7??? I can't understand that.

Isn't 8.5 a good score? I don't get the anger and the 15+ pgs comments on ign debating a 0.5 difference.

Of course it is a good score. But they gave Star Fox 64 3d an 9.0 and the original score was 8.7, and gave the original Ocarina of time an 10 and the 3ds remake got an 9.5. It seems that they think this one is not as good as the original one, or that the game has not stood the test of time.