I'm a fan of linear AND non-linear games.
I liked that Uncharted was fairly straightforward, simply because I enjoyed it at the time I was playing it. I knew I would only need to play it once to get the whole story, but I've replayed it a couple of times just because I wanted to.
There are games that are non-linear (I'm playing DA:Origins just now) that I love too. Its a whole different gaming experience, but I probably couldn't choose between them if I was asked.
I don't think non-linearity should be a negative thing, its just different. As long as I get my fill of both, I'm happy.







