Mmm Madden 12 trophy list seem achievable.( no online but a bunch of Madden Ultimate team trophies which is ok by me)
http://www.ps3trophies.org/game/madden-nfl-12/trophies/
Just not sure if I am going to purchase the game or not this year ( I played the shit out of Madden 10 but didn't spend that much time in 11).
PS : the build an 80 rated MUT team is going to be a major pain though, you're talking either spending a fortune buying cards or spending a lot of time in that mode...