| dsage01 said: I'm still shocked about what happened with Uncharted 2. They were both great games one of the best action/adventure games this gen. But Uncharted 2 really made sony fanboys put down the 360 fanboys by a lot. And that was there game of the gen. But I'm shocked it only landed in 5th place |
TBH it only landed where it did because of the move to pit PS3 vs PS3 titles and give Reach second chances and try and give 360 titles a chance to compete. Whether by demographic choice or whatever it's pretty clear that in a straight poll on the site the big PS3 exclusives would take the top spots. Wthe 36hat it did show (hopefully the 360 fans will see you can extrapolate the results in this manner) is that the real key to winning polls like this online isn't have the biggest sales but the most dedicated mini-fanbase. Personally, from what I've seen it seems likely number 1 should be MGS4 as it surely has the most ferocious fanbase on the site, followed probably by GoW3 in second then Uncharted 2 in third, after that I'm not too sure which fanbase would win out for the remaining positions.
Sorry to complain but TBH for me the poll lost the plot a while back with such moves... when you have to change the rules mid competition and give titles "free passes" the results don't really matter much anymore it seems to me.
But hey... plenty of fun moments in the discussion around games.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
