By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
TruckOSaurus said:
Here's the list of alleged night actions for reference:

Night 0

Truck -> Baalzamon
Baalzamon -> Hephaestos
prof -> Hephaestos
Hephaestos (Vigilante) -> Final-Fan
Final-Fan/Wonk -> Baalzamon

Night 1

Truck -> Hephaestos
Baalzamon -> Final-Fan
prof -> Final-Fan
Hephaestos (Vigilante) -> ?
Final-Fan/Wonk -> prof

Night 2

Truck -> prof
Baalzamon -> ?
prof -> ?
Heph -> Dead
Wonk -> ?

First things first.  I lied about my night 1 action.  I targeted Heph.  I was scared out of my mind that should I have admitted it, it would immediately be assumed I was the mafia (and I myself thought I was the mafia).  Fortunately (and I completely understand that it immediately becomes hard to believe what I say when I just admitted to lying), my target last night was not Wonk.  I targeted you last night.

So I've been working away on my paper to try and figure this out, and I think I have it.  Heph did indeed target FF on night 0.  This means that somebody else was lying, and actually targeted Trucks.  Clearly Trucks can't target himself.  I was far too scared to lie to any degree whatsoever on day 0, nor was it necessary, because the person I targeted (Heph) did not die.  This leaves Prof as our killer.  So on night 0, Prof actually targeted you, Trucks.  Wonk, our doctor, targeted me, Heph targeted Wonk.  But somebody had to have blocked Heph's kill.  If Prof is lying, I am actually the only person who targeted Heph on night 0.  This leaves me as the roleblocker, and you, Trucks, as the townie.

Now, on night 1, I targeted and blocked Heph's kill.  Prof lied once again, and actually targeted Heph.  Heph, who we do not know who he targeted, could have targeted anybody, and it doesn't matter, because it was blocked.  You claim you targeted Heph as well, but once again, it does not matter, because you are just a townie.  Wonk, our doctor, targeted Prof, but since it wasn't the person who was going to die, there was no effect.

For night 2, you already admitted to targetting Prof.  Since you are the townie, this had no effect whatsoever.  Prof, being the mafia, targeted Wonk.  I targeted you last night.  Roleblocking the townie clearly had no effect.  No matter who Wonk targeted (Prof, you, or I), it had no effect since that person wouldn't have died.

Literally every single other scenario I have went through either requires so much lying it is unbelievable that it could not possibly be true or simply does not work.

For the simple reason that I know I suck at coming up with these scenarios, I'm not yet going to vote for Prof.  I want to make sure I can go through it myself several more times, as well as give you an opportunity to look at it before I put a vote out.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.