Head to Head

[AlkamistStar]

My choice is for Alan Wake.

I had more fun playing Alan Wake, but preferred the story of Heavy Rain. The mysteriousness of the Origami Killer was more involving as a player, but the Dark Presence in Alan Wake was more intriguing to figure out. Alan Wake's pace was faster than Heavy Rain which I appreciated on my second play-through of both games. Heavy Rain required me to constantly replay chapters to finally get my Platinum, and the slow pacing made it almost unbearable on occasion.