HappySqurriel said:
High taxes do cause problems, and tax and spend is implicitly a bad idea, but a few countries with low corruption and citizens who are not selfish can make it operate in a moderately successful fashion. |
These countries aren't only operating in moderately succesfully - they have some of the highest qualities of life in the world. There is no reason for it to be intrinsically a bad idea - it simply relies on good governance to work.
There are arguments why it wouldn't work in America so well (as I said, it relies on good governance to work, plus America is has a much larger population than these countries) but the fact is that in the right country - a wealthy, small and highly developed state - it works exceptionally well.