Reasonable on 06 July 2011
These comparisons seem rather odd to me.
R2 and Reach is odd vs say comparing Killzone 3 with Reach, and Gears 2 (gory, silly, over the top shooting TPS action online) vs MGS 4 (somewhat serious, stealth based TPS, tactical online) seems like an odd one too.
I've voted Reach and MGS 4 so far, but the titles are so far apart in some cases you're talking personal taste vs a sensible ability to compare gameplay, level design, etc.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
