Definitely the Dual Shock 3. I like the aligned analog sticks, the D-pad, as well as the size and shape. The 360 controller has some strange design decisions that make it worse IMO. The D-pad stinks and there's this ridge on each side where you place your hands around the grips which, after an extended gaming session, begins to dig into your fingers. Though, I don't find the swapped left stick and D-pad a hindrance. On the other hand, I fail to see it as being any better for gaming.
The only thing that would make the Dual Shock perfect is if the analog sticks and trigger buttons were concave and not convex. Guess that will come for the Dual Shock 4.







