By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
richardhutnik on 22 June 2011
Edit Thread
Akvod said:
richardhutnik said:
kivi95 said:
Their is no reason to own MW3 just to own BF3. Buy quality game instead.

If there is no reason to own MW3, that still doesn't mean there is a reason to own BF3.  For simple FPS action, with a group of people together, I have Black Ops (bots, Dead Ops arcade, Zombies) and also MW2 (for the Spec Ops mode).  I see MW3 offers its own version of the hoard mode, and if it also supports 4 player split screen and hoard mode, then it is worth considering for me.

So, I am not interested in a Call of Duty replacement, unless it does every single thing I have now (I doubt BF3 does), but provides a justifiable reason to get it.  And that is the heart of the matter.  What is BF3 bringing to the table, that justifies it being owned by me on its own merits? 


Buy Bad Company 2, or Bad Company 1 (will be hard to find full, quality games at this point though) to find out for yourself.

I think you're looking too broadly. When you say "FPS action, with a group of people together" you should not buy any other game than Modern Warfare.

The way you should be thinking though, is what TYPE of FPS action does Battlefield offer?

1) Destruction and open maps.

2) Vehicles

Yeah, this is ending up becoming a wall of text, so I'll stop XD

Ok, I reduced what you wrote down to the section headers.

I HAD owned both Bad Company 1 and Bad Company 2.  I enjoyed the story of Bad Company 1, and felt they tried to go the direction Modern Warfare 2 did, because I guess it felt more epic.  I missed the humor of the original, and the entire going wrong and becoming mercenaries.  They threw that out.  UGH!    

Anyhow, there are reasons why I don't own either now.  Big one was the lack of four player split screen.  When all things are said and done, I would need an FPS to have four player split screen in the event that I would be doing a shooter with friends.  Bad Company lacks that.  I don't play online at all.  Black Ops gave me bots, which was a plus.  Bad Company 1, which I kept over Bad Company 2, ended up going in a purge of games I had, for store credit, so I could get more stuff.

So, in short, what you are saying is that it doesn't really extend the category with new modes, but happens to provide more, and attempts to do it better.