Interesting take on the 2k pr mess.

[hxczuner]

Dodece said:
@Staude

There is a hypocrisy in such arguments...So if good content can make a game awesome then it is only logical that supremely bad content can see a game being marked down to total crap.

Exactly. It doesn't matter how "broken" a game is, as long as it's worth pushing through. Basically, different people value different aspects of games. 1Up (and most games writers) value game content and fun factor over a lack of glitches or performance issues. They very well could've just been bashing the game, I won't count that out, but the score reflects the level of fun they had with the game.