VGChartz Playstation Trophy League

[Esquoret]

Arcturus said:

KylieDog said:
I still say LA Noire is 1 star, and I have that plat now. If it is gonna stay 3 then the platinum league turning into a joke. Too many easy games getting high ratings and games that are harder getting lower ones.

What exactly in LA Noire is even close to being equally as challenging as beating CoD World at War on Veteran? Or the Spec Ops missions in MW2? Or Dead Space 2 on hardcore? It is apparently harder than Impossible in Dead Space 1.

There is sod all challenging in LA Noire. Nothing.

@ yakuzaIce, chenguo4, finalsquall, HideoK: After earning the plat for LA Noire, what do you think the difficulty rating for LA Noire should be? 

I'm just about to get the platinum too - like in about 20min. (just gotta get one more case 5 stars)

I'd like to argue that LA Noire is anything but a 1 star.

The Auto Fanatic trophy is a tricky collectible trophy, because what you're trying to collect appears fairly random (80% of the locations using guides actually don't work) and are moving some of the time, as they're cars on the road. And the cars are sometimes very similar in design, which makes finding the one even harder. Not to mention that the map is huge. Some people spend a couple of hours looking for a single model - that time is equivalent to the time needed to finish a lot of 1 star games.

So one game takes a couple of swift hours to get the platinum, the other a couple of frustrating hours to find one collectible (out of 95) for a single trophy. This is one argument that the two games cannot both be 1 star.