EDGE New Batch of Reviews (inFAMOUS 2, LA Noire, Witcher 2, Brink, Dirt 3)

[JEMC]

After reading their review for The Witcher 2, I get the idea that:
1-They don't like the fact that you can't create your character or choose your class. Anyone who buys this game already knows that.
2-The first act is too slow. Fair point.
3-The combat is not precise and you need to adquire talents. That's the point of the game, you start knowing little only to learn more and become more powerful.
4-Some bugs. Again, fair point although there have been 2 patches that may have solved some of those.

How can a game with only 1 major downside get a 6!