it got a 3/10 from me, reasons:
-The kinect stuff was really underwhelming, both kinect sports 2 and dance central 2 looked exactly the same as the originals, and both the Disneyland and sesame street games where disgracefully bad. Star wars was the best thing shown off for it and that was still pretty basic from a gameplay standpoint. Ryse really disappointed me as i really thought that would have been a core game. Ghost recon was the only decent kinect idea there.
-The core games were mostly disappointing mainly due to nothing non-halo was announced. The gears and forza demo's were ok, although they were pretty much what i expected. I remember on the VGA awards on spike CliffyB said they had a huge surprise and thought they might announce it there but it never happened. Halo anniversary was definatley my favorite thing of the show so far, although i have played and finished that game so I'm not really excited. Halo 4 also had a pretty "put together at the last minute" sort of trailer.
-On the xbox live things were ok, the youtube and bing services were good but overall i didnt really see anything I'd use. I have to say they should have announced the cloud saving feature, which they announced after, on stage, it was by far the best new feature they have. Minecraft was good too but does it really need kinect?
Overall, pretty disappointing but they seem to have a good enough christmas lineup to call this year a success and I suppose the kinect stuff was better than it could have been.
End of 2012 prediction:
xbox 360 : 73-75 million 
playstation 3 : 72-74 million wii : 104-105 million 
Most hyped for :
Bioshock: infinte, The Last Of Us, Alan Wake's American Nightmare and Agent
