L.A. Noire. Worst Ending Ever Thought Of? SPOILERS!!!!!!

[adriane23]

Acevil said:

Given I haven't read this thread, I do agree this was one of the worse endings I have seen in gaming history. In Red Dead it made sense, but in this game it was unnecessary. 

However, I think they do leave his death as questionable, since it was closed coffin, and that typically means two things, one regards the condition of the body, the other is when you are MIA. 

Yeah, I felt the same way. In RDR (SPOILERS!!!) Marston was murdered by the government to tie up their loose ends (END SPOILERS). And as soon as he told Kelso to go up before him, I knew what was about to happen which was completely cliche. A better point would've been to have Phelps live to deal with his demons. Death always seems to be the easy cop out in stories like these.

I was thinking this too, but it would just be really "soap opera-ish" for lack of a better term for this type of game. I think it was closed casket cuz he was probably completely crushed by the impact of the water or his skin tissue was bloated/waterlogged by the time they recovered his body.