By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
o_O.Q said:

Alby_da_Wolf said:

[...]

1. Those that don't respect the others' rights can and must be stopped, and punished if what they did is a crime. But only them and nobody else.

2. Medication used correctly benefits the minority that needs it and it doesn't harm anybody else. The same applies to hacks and mods, their correct use benefits a minority and it doesn't harm anybody else. BTW people abusing medications, if psychoactive ones, can harm also people not using them, the analogies are more than it seems at the first look. In both cases the solution is enforcing the abidance of laws and rules in every context where others can be affected, not depriving minorances of things that can benefit them also and possibly mainly in ways that don't harm others.

yes agreed, but the point is that when geohot posted the keys online anyone who wanted to do these malicious acts was given the ability to do so... obviously some hackers will not interfere in the network and will not pirate but the point is that some will

"The same applies to hacks and mods, their correct use benefits a minority and it doesn't harm anybody else."

I'm kind of getting tired repeating the same thing over and over... do you own a ps3? if you did you would understand that the hacking communtiy ( at least the ones on ps3 ) does not follow your those guidelines they interfere in the online activities of users, for example for the third time :

"when the hacking community took over CoD on the ps3 and made it unplayable"

bear in mind that that only happened after geohot posted the keys online

I'm a PC gamer, but cheaters and other dickheads exist on every platform. This doesn't give either me or you the right to avenge ourselves on innocents.

PS3 hack hit Sony so hard because it made the wrong assumption that it could reach ultimate security. As I already wrote, it was just an illusion, and when Sony understood it, millions of vulnerable consoles had been already sold and were available to both benevolent and malicious hackers to study. Unless Sony bought them all back, they were available to study and hack, and the hackers had all the time they needed, nothing could stop them anymore. At that point, with or without GeoHot the situation was compromised, and the right solution for new consoles wasn't to remove OtherOS, but to patch or rewrite the hypervisor and redesign the virtual machine structure used, and to watch more accurately PSN to kick away cheaters. Blaming GeoHot and hoping that stopping him all could get back like before is totally utopian. It's like a Pandora's box, but in this case it was neither GeoHot nor other hackers that opened it, they just discovered that Sony left it open instead. At that point, like I already wrote too, the only effective strategy Sony can choose for PSN is the same of other networks and the same used by casinos too: watching carefully and ceaselessly. And for PS3, checking and patching the firmware promptly and accepting only units with authorized firmware in its network to play. These things would have been effective also to protect CoD multiplayer. Scapegoats didn't actually take evils away 3000 years ago and they never started working since then, either.



Stwike him, Centuwion. Stwike him vewy wuffly! (Pontius Pilate, "Life of Brian")
A fart without stink is like a sky without stars.
TGS, Third Grade Shooter: brand new genre invented by Kevin Butler exclusively for Natal WiiToo Kinect. PEW! PEW-PEW-PEW!