Isn't the question of which is worst really a two part question? Which was worse for the consumer? Which was worse for the companies involved?
For the consumer, it's subjective. But I think over all PSN wasis worse. It's going to cost Sony more than the 1 billion it cost Microsoft for the RRoD. Developers are losing money. Millions of consumers personal info got compromised. Sony's overall image took more of a blow as compared to Microsoft. Maybe it's the way it's being reported, maybe it's the difference in PR tactics. Also, it wasn't just PSN, it was SOE as well. So definately, at least public image wise, Sony will suffer the most out of those respective fiascos.







