Seriously giving this a 2 or a 3 you must never ever have liked a Rockstar game and was therefore bound to hate it.
The lowest score in this round of threads has been a 4 and then this gets a 2? I don't like people giving away 10s too easily, but this is nuts.
Together with Mass Effect 2 this is absolutely the game of 2010.
I was going to give this a 9.5 because there's only a very slight chance I'll ever want to beat it a second time and I think a perfect game should have some replayability even years after.
I was also a little dissappointed by the amount of content of the Undead Nightmare, probably because I had too high expectations.
Last thing I want to mention is that getting insta-killed by a mountain lion and losing hours of flower and animal hunting progress sucks.
My score: 10.0