Elpresador says "Gears of War 3 is Garbage"

[d21lewis]

CGI-Quality said:

d21lewis said:

I feel the same way.  This game is prettty but unlovable.  I even loaned it to a co-worker in exchange for WWE All-Stars.  The next day, he brought it back.  Didn't even ask for his game, he just brought it back!  The last game I took back to the store was Velvet Assassin.  That ggame was a broken mess.  I'm taking KZ3 back today.  I usually keep every game I buy because there's a certain charm or feeling that I'll be in the mood to play it someday.  With KZ3, I don''t feel anything when I play it.  It's gotta go.

I'm actually pretty surprised to see you chime in and continue to derail the topic, but I'll make this short and sweet: your piece only means you didn't like the game, not that the game is bad. Look at how many people don't like the Gears 3 beta (the Epic forums are the best place to look). Something tells me you wouldn't agree with those folks.

Yeah, me too.  I avoided the Killzone 3 ranking game, pretty much kept my opinion to myself, and even gave the game a 9/10 in my initial review.  I just saw the post in this thread and realized that i felt the same way.  Like you said, it's just an opinion.  I'm sure it's beloved by many.  Just not me.  Like "Elpressador" in his GeoW3 Beta video (which I haven't watched), the FPS genre is one that has never been a favorite of mine.  I managed to find some fun in games like Quake II, Godeneye, Timesplitters, Red Faction, Halo series, Bioshock, and the CoD series.  I just found nothing to even compell me to finish the campaign in Killzone aside from its beauty and even then, that wasn't enough.  I know I'll never play the game again, despite its technical prowess.  Something I can't say about games I know are terrible and yet still find a home on my shelves.  I feel the same way about the Madden series.  Take my opinion with a grain of salt.  It's just that.  An opinion.

--Changed my personal review on my "my games" page, too.  It's a quality game that isn't for me.