Final-Fan said:
1.
It's not that actions don't have consequences, it's the specific consequences that are being questioned. Why does some stuff send you to Hell? A lot of it doesn't seem to make much sense other than "because God said so", and that's not a reason any better than "because your dictator said so".
Faith is fine, but you have to stop confusing what is good enough for you as an answer and what is objectively a good answer for everyone -- and remember, unless I'm mistaken you are saying this applies to everyone.
From my perspective, I think your relationship may well be completely one-sided. It's like you're being held hostage. Back when they came in to rob the bank, they made everyone sit on the floor. A couple were near the exit, and one of the robbers egged them on to try to escape. The woman convinced the man they should run for it, but they got shot. Then one of them shot the guy who egged them on. He said, "We don't want to hurt you. That guy was sadistic or something, I don't know but it won't happen again. At least if you don't try to escape." Well, that guy Joe is pretty friendly, and you feel like you're real good pals now, he gets you stuff from the vending machine and you just know that it'll all be okay as soon as they get their money and get away. You're even thinking of joining them. Someone sitting near you is muttering something about Stockholm syndrome. The worst part of it all is that the whole thing is in your head! There are no God robbers.
The point of that story is not to offend but to try to illustrate a point. Jesus' sacrifice is for what? Original sin, along with, I suppose, all the rest of the stuff your ANCESTORS did. Why is that your fault? God said so. What happens if you don't acknowledge all the stuff that they did as your fault and how awesome it was that Jesus took care of that inherited baggage for you? Hell. Why? God said so. See a pattern here?
In fact, God being omnipotent and omniscient and all, he knew all of that was going to happen before he even created the universe. Now I wouldn't blame him for all the bad stuff people have done, even if I believed in him, but I would say he gets an EQUAL share of blame since he made it happen just as surely as the people with the blood on their hands. So, in a way, he made SURE those people were going to go to Hell before the Earth was even formed. If he didn't want it to play out that way, he could have just made the universe differently, but he chose not to. How loving does that sound?
2.
I think you are being pretty dishonest here, let's go back a couple steps in the quote box: "More, you act like having no freedom and living in fear of a dictator, that gives you no real choice, that doesn`t love you or care about you, is the same as someone who loves you, died for you, lets you choose and gives everything to make you happy."
Now you are making it sound there like the choices are not something imposed on you by God but just regular old free will that you can take or leave with no more consequences than anyone would face as the natural result of whatever actions they took (instead of arbitrary punishment like imprisonment for political disagreement with dictators).
Let's contrast that with "It`s a choice, you might not like the outcome but it`s still a choice, as honest choice that you base solely on your will. Freedom." Now it sounds more like you're saying, "Well, he knew what would happen if he spoke up to Stalin like that, so nobody can say he didn't know the consequences. It was his choice, he made it freely."
3. See the last two paragraphs of (1), adding to the second-to-last paragraph, "And while we're at it, why does it sometimes sound like people can't walk across the room or fart without committing a sin? Who decided doing anything and everything was a sin anyway? Oh yeah, God."
|
