So how many GOTY awards has each game won?

[rocketpig]

Updated to include GI and IGN: 

BioShock:

Spike TV Awards

BAFTA Awards

X-Play Awards

Game Informer

Call of Duty 4:

GamePro

GameSpy

The Orange Box:

Eurogamer (for Portal)

Super Mario Galaxy:

GameSpot

GameTrailers

Yahoo

Edge

Kotaku

IGN 

(VGChartz, NeoGAF but they don't really count)