MikeB on 11 January 2008
@ rocketpig
I doubt 4 out of 5 people who actually played both games till the end prefer Gears. IMO Gears was overhyped especially by the US gaming press like many other 360 games, not sure why. I guess the graphics played an important part, maybe still the most impressive the 360 has seen to date. Maybe because its on the 360, I doubt the same game on the PS3 would have been given such ratings.
The PC version seems actually better but scored quite a bit worse. You for instance don't get this in the 360 version (maybe if the 360 version wouldn't have gotten such high scores, the PC scores may have been lower still):
http://youtube.com/watch?v=NQSL1Ke8QsU
