Nintendo Wii2 (what ever it is) will fail if its going after the PS360 crowd.
If so the reasons Nintendo will fail:
1. Nintendo has an terrible record on Online gameplay: Freind codes: no player is going to dump there xbox live or PSN for friend codes even if the graphics are better.
2. 3rd party support: Nintendos past console the Wii had Nintendos games Dominating most of the time while 3rd party games struggled, will they invest in the new console? It will most likely be the Port Box for the first 2 years unless:
3. First Party Studios Exclusives: Nintendo have the money and if developing an console to go after PS3 and 360 they must buy up western development studios, An have exclusive title deals with EA, TakeTwo, Activison etc to get some hot IP onto the Box, because they are only going to port planned PS360 titles to the console not untilizing its new power and will not draw gamers to invest the requred 400-500 dollars for the machine.
4. The nintendo wii appealed to the causal gamer: it was simple and "Family Friendly", so when mothers saw this on adds during Opar and Ellen they rushed out and bought it for there kids and wiifit. An in order to draw the 100 million cashed up juciy console gamers over they need IP's they like and showing off call of duty during above show isn't going to get the mothers rushing to the stores.
The only way i can see this not becoming the next Dreamcast which was an early bloomer Bomb from Sega is some serious investment into the online department with an Brand new service that is Free and better than Steam!, Some exlcusives IP's from such publishers are Activison, EA and TakeTwo, bethsda as well. If Nintendo can pull what SONY has lined up this year in terms of exclusives with the best online network then there is nothing stopping them from doing an xbox360.
Of Course That's Just My Opinion, I Could Be Wrong







