Which game will get a higher meta score? Uncharted 3 or Gears 3?

[Troll_Whisperer]

Jay520 said:

I've realized something about games that get really high metacritics (93 ). They all fall into one of these categories:

1. They are new IPs (LBP, Bioshock, Gears of War)
2. They are new to the generation (GTA IV, MGS4, RDR)
3. They have a previous game this gen that wasn't rated really high (Un-charted 2, Mass Effect 2)

The only exception I can think of is SMG2 & MW2.  For that reason, I see UC3 & GeOW3 getting 93 tops.

Dude, 90% of the games fall in one of those categories

You may as well say "only games that follow a really high scoring game within the same generation don't get high metacritics". And even then, you found exceptions in SMG2 and MW2, lol.

Anyway, OP: To close to know, but I'm going to bet U3. Regardless, I believe both will be insanely high, despite high expectations.