Damn, I want to see Khuutra post here. 
Ok, here's my take:
PROS
- Great voice acting
- Loyalty missions were great
- Game story is very good (the whole thing about the genophage alone was awesome)
- Great graphics
- Playing on the hardest difficulty is awesome when you learn to use the powers right (game is well designed/balanced)
- Amazing Soundtrack ( I still isten to Suicide Mission almost everyday)
- "I am the very model of a salarian scientist" 
CONS
- A bit too streamlined
- Has middle child complex (but thats what happens when you are the second game of a trilogy)
- Some characters are annoying (ex. Jacob)
- Completely linear
- The whole paragon/renegade choices are often too clear-cut (no shades of grey)
SCORE: 9.0









