Has the Wii failed as a gamer console?

[Pavolink]

M.U.G.E.N said:

I don't see how on-rail shooters are good in any way or form compared to regular shooters....might be a personal preference

It really depends on the developer. I heard that Sin & Punishment is good. Personally, I enjoy a lot more both On-rail Chornicles on Wii than RE5 (X360 version), but prefer RE4 freedom compared with these.

Maybe one example is Dead Space. 1 and 2 are better experiences that Extraction for the majority of gamers. Still on-rails shooters are games and some people like.