8.6
.1 better than an 8.5.
GOOD:
One of the best stories and most engaging stories in video gaming history
A real feeling of "wow I am controlling this universe and the outcome, I'd better not screw it up!"
I cared about the characters
Good ending(s)
Most QTEs were very fun
Had the only female video game character that I actually thought was good looking (a testament to the graphics and storytelling), and absolutely the only VG character whose boobs I wanted to see. And I DID!!!
NOT GOOD:
Little replay value (though worth the $60, an interesting dichotomy)
Awful, awful controls walking and running
Some sequences were really lame
In general, one of my favorite games I've ever experienced. More fun to experience than it is to play - the actual video game mechanics were not great (like Indigo Prophecy)
