Omg. Where to start.
I've looked at your game collection and from what I can see you love horror games and platformers as well as first-person shooters.
I say get one at a time not to be overwhelmed.
I don't know lately I feel like recommending inFamous. It's an amazing game and it would get you ready for the sequel.
There's always the Uncharted series but I don't know if it's your thing. Best way to know is to try.