I think people are confusing games that didn't age well with games that always sucked. For example, Battle Arena Toshinden. That game came packed with my PS1 and it got a 98% in PSM magazine. Sofia from BAT was even the default Sony mascot for a while. I couldn't wait to play it. Unfortunately, they were blinded by 3D boobies or something. I played that game in 1996 and it sucked so bad that after I beat it, I took the game out of my PS1 and bit the fuck out of it. It was horrid and no amount of nostalgia and "Oh, we had such a great time with that game!" will convince me otherwise.