I did two full playthroughs and collected all of the SP trophies. MP is not my thing, so I am not commenting on that.
I think the game is good, but for it to be great then the suits resources would needed to have been fundamentaly integrated into the gameplay. It's nice to have the suits options but they aren't necessarily critical to your success.
The story features two compelling charcters and a few over the top, out of context assholes, and is largely nonsensical. The stuff directly involoving the suit and Prophet is great.
The sandbox level designs are nice yet shallow; you don't have to walk straight forward to shoot someone, but ultimately the areas aren't large enough to create a truly dynamic gaming experience. There are no rewards for exploring, you still start at point A and walk to point B.
Graphically it's good. The stand out is the lighting; it is excellent. I like this better than anything that has been produced using UE3. But drawing straight lines on buildings is hardly representative of how good an engine is.
And the suit, for how impressive it looks and all if its features, it's kinda wimpy. If you watch the opening sequences, you are absolutely crushing fools, and then you play the game, you have to wonder if maybe your suit is a defect.
That being said, it is a fun FPS, set in a world filled with great lighting. I recommend it to anyone who is a fan of the genre. 8.5/10
I wouldn't be surprised if this gets GOTY nominations.
