After playing the game extensively I can say that it's the best in many categories. I believe the answer depends on if you hold open environments with all of the effects going on higher then all of the pop in, inconsistent framerate and some poor textures.
Personally, if it can't run consistently then I can't hold it atop of the mountain. It reminds me of when Half Life 2 was brought to the xbox. It was amazing that they could bring such a technical game to console, but then it couldn't run to standards. Still, it's a beautiful game and I've had a blast with it. I love the tactical options that the game gives you, and gameplay wise it's leaps and bounds better than killzone 3's sp option. But the story couldn't be any more bland and I never once cared about a single one of the vague and bland objectives.
I know that a lot of the people on the net are jumping at the chance to call this game the best looking console game if only because it appears on 360 and that the 360 arguably has the stronger version, and to those people I would say, stop trying so hard. Rage comes out in september, will undoubtably be the best looking console game released and I would be surprised if the 360 didn't have the superior version because it's coming from a pc dev. Your day is coming in all of it's 60 fps goodness.
