MW2/BO of course, gets way too much praise for being what we've seen since counter-strike and they're exactly the same as the first MW.
MW2 = Copy of MW
BO = copy of a copy
Other shooting games I think are overrated are Killzone-series, GoW-series, Halo-series, Battlefield-series. All just feel like a graphical pissing contest to me, without any worthwhile new ideas. They have one good idea that they just use in the next 3 games in the series with minor graphical updates and they sell overpriced-DLC, like map packs containing maps from the earlier game...
I also dislike nintendo's rotation of the same games, Zelda peaked in OoT for N64 and Mario in SMB3 for NES. Pokemon is also the most overrated series imo, I got bored of it after the first game I had for Gameboy Color 10 years ago. I have no interest in metroid.
Bethesda/Obsidian for ruining Fallout by making it an oblivion-clone, the customization is simplistic and roleplaying aspect is as weak as Oblivions was. It also has some horrible voice-actors straight from oblivion.
FFXIII for having a terrible storyline/Characters and the game was just a long pipe-run, I'm still struggling to finish the damn thing! I stopped playing during chapter 12. I also dislike the automated battles, they could have added some AI-control commands like in Dragon Age Origins, FGS! and when PC-dies = game over, I hate that too.
Bayonetta, too much fanservice for my taste and yet again terrible storyline/characters.
Dynasty Warriors/Samurai Warriors = Recycle, recycle, recycle...
Motion Control/Casual-games, I'd prefer if devs would use their cash trying to make a good videogame in all aspects (with awesome story/characters, solid gameplay and lot of content) rather than a casual: "It's fun for 15 minutes, after that you've seen all it has to offer"-games.
