By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
System/Game Mass Effect 2 Alan Wake Left 4 Dead 2 God of War 3 Total
PC x   x   2
PS3 x     x 2
Xbox 360 x x x   3

OR

System/Exclusive Mass Effect 2 Alan Wake Left 4 Dead 2 God of War 3 Total
PC          
PS3       x 1
Xbox 360   x     1

Which is the right way to consider game libraries? 

There's more than one way of looking at things but lately, it seems like people prefer to look at the 2nd way instead of the first when it comes to determining the quality of a game console's library.  Is it better to include everything (Table "A") and take the worth of a particular device's library as a whole?  Is it better to omit certain games and just look at 100% exclusives (Table "B")?  I don't know anymore.  Depending on how you look at things, the entire picture changes.  Which is the best way?

--Keep in mind that this is just an example.  I don't know what the picture would look like if we counted only retail games, included downloadable games, tossed a Wii out of a window, or imagined Kinect games as real games.  I just want to know if we should count everything or give 100% exclusives more weight.