Box art comparison thread - Suikoden

[twesterm]

mchaza said:

twesterm said:

You could at least pick two boxes where it's not completely obvious which one is better.  What are you going to do next, Ico?

that completly defeats the purpose of discussion. the american box art shouldn't of been made in the first place 

A discussion would be discussing why they made they made the NA boxart and others like it like they did.  What this thread and the countless ones before it turn into is people saying the NA one sucks, why did they have to change it to suck?