Uncharted 3 Vs Gears of War 3

[huaxiong90]

BenVTrigger said:

Aldro said:

Uncharted 3 is going to rape this poll, mark my words.

obviously, I can't think of a single pole in the history of this site where something 360 related defeated something PS3 related.  In fact not sure if its ever happened.

Pretty sure Halo 3 beat out Killzone 2 in an earlier poll.

OT: I LOVED Gears of War 1. It only lacks in the story IMO (and it seems Epic are trying to take it seriously, which is why I take issue with it), but it's easily the most arcade-ish TPS I've played ever. The online is fun, but the balancing can be pretty bad, and the netcode isn't that great. But Gears of War 2 disappointed me. Very cheesy campaign (and not very immersive), and very piss poor netcoding.

Still, my hopes are high for Gears of War 3.

Now, Uncharted...I love the whole adventurous feel of it, and it's pretty immersive with its story and characters. Problem is, it feels like a roller coaster ride with both games...in other words, I don't feel they're replayable like GoW1 was (and even 2). But Uncharted 2 had a really fun online, so that overall makes it the best game of the four, IMO, with Uncharted: DF being the least favorite (though I still loved it).

Gonna have to go with Uncharted 3. But I'm VERY excited for both games overall.