MikeB said:
It's true, quoting myself from a couple of months before Kinect launched:
"The IMO top three biggest problems with Kinect is:
1) A very noticeable response lag. This kills the potential of fast paced accurate gaming. In part this is due to the too slow camera and in part due to the additional processing going on taking too much time.
2) No analog stick/buttons or triggers. It can't recognize seperate fingers, so even pretending you are pulling an imaginary trigger on an imaginary gun won't work (which IMO would be ackward anyway, holding nothing and pretending). Also look at the Starwars game under development, you can't rotate your view nor manually walk this while lightsaber slashes display notieable lag...
3) The camera is IMO far too big and ugly and pretty expensive for what you get.
Technical specifications Playstation Eye vs Kinect cameras:
Kinect in addition to normal camera also includes an infrared camera, which could allow it to do better in different light situations, but likely not in the case of Playstation Eye Playstation Move cases for most games.
Horizontal field of view:
Kinect: 57 degrees
Playstation Eye: 75 degrees
Vertical field of view:
Kinect: 43 degrees
Playstation Eye: 56 degrees
With 16 bit color depth:
Kinect: 320 x 240 @ 30 FPS
Playstation Eye: 320 x 240 @ 120 FPS
With 32 bit color depth:
Kinect: - (not supported)
Playstation Eye: 640 x 480 @ 60 FPS
Audio:
Kinect: 16 bit audio @ 16 kHz
Playstation Eye: 16 bit audio @ 48 kHz"
I tried to warn people, but many were just too hyped (like for the fake Milo demo). I find Kinect to be pretty destructive for hardcore gaming on the XBox. Half of the XBox game shelf space here is now dedicated to predominantly crappy Kinect-only games.
I also mentioned the additional resource requirement compared to Move and I find his comments interesting that he just like me thinks Kinect is mostly usefull for dancing/exercises games/programs, that's exactly what I once wrote. IMO don't expect much hardcore game support for Kinect, unlike for Playstation Move.
|
You forgot to compare the specs of the depth camera.
