By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
twesterm said:
chocoloco said:
twesterm said:
chocoloco said:
AussieGecko said:
chocoloco said:

Any new game not published by Microsoft Studios will just be a time exclusive in my MInd. Microsoft prove me wrong.


they have with gears... you shouldnt ignore that factor

They have had gears since launch, most of us are looking for something new and Kinect anything does not count unless I have the option to play with or without it.

If you didn't have to use Kinect then wouldn't it be nothing new?

Of course it would be new, its like saying a brand new truck model is not new every year because there is no new way to drive it.        


Right, but you're saying something is only new if it has Kinect AND can still be played with a controller.  That implies that you or something would like to play whatever it is with traditional controls which implies that traditionally controleld games can still be new...so your statement doesn't make sense.

  • Most of us are looking for something new
  • Kinect does not count as new unless it has both control sets
  • Therefore, a game with Kinect controls can be new
  • Therefore, a game without Kinect controls can be new
  • Therefore, any game cannot be new regardless of Kinect controls.

There is fault in my arguement if your looking at from the perspective of a person who actually wants to play kinect. I'm writing from a bias of someone who will not buy anything that works with kinect alone. I report my own biases and cannot predict what others will enjoy or appreciate. So with or without kinect it is new, some will be happy because it is new because they like or want kinect. The other group will look at it as Microsoft giving them nothing because they have no interest in kinect.

So if something works only with kinect it must interest me alone to make it worthwhile in my eyes. I am just hoping microsoft is able to please everyone by making kinect games that also function with the traditional 360 control system.